Auto Insurance

Cheap Car Insurance With Bad Credit: How to Pay Less

Hunting for cheap car insurance with bad credit can feel like a surcharge on your financial past, and in most states that description is pretty close to accurate. Carriers price policies off credit-based insurance scores, so drivers with poor credit usually pay 60% to 115% more than people with excellent credit for the exact same coverage. Ahead: the companies that lean on credit the least, the states where the practice is outlawed, and concrete moves that lower a premium in weeks instead of years.

What Weak Credit Really Does to Your Premium

Your FICO number isn't what an insurer looks at. They order a credit-based insurance score, a proprietary figure built to forecast claim frequency instead of loan default. LexisNexis and TransUnion sell those scores to most large carriers, and the link between weak credit and heavier claims — documented by federal studies in the mid-2000s — is still how the industry defends the practice.

The financial damage is not small. Anyone sitting below roughly 580 on the traditional scale frequently pays 60% to 115% above an excellent-credit customer on an identical policy. In more than a few states, that credit surcharge runs higher than what the same company charges for one at-fault crash or a first DUI.

Picture a 35-year-old in Ohio with a spotless record and a 550 credit score paying roughly $2,400 a year for full coverage, while the same driver holding a 780 score pays nearer $1,200 — identical vehicle, identical ZIP code, identical limits. That distance stretches wider in places like Michigan and Louisiana, where base rates already rank among the nation's steepest.

Carriers That Go Easiest on Low Credit Scores

Companies don't penalize weak credit at the same rate. Filings submitted to state regulators show these carriers applying lighter credit surcharges than the national norm:

• USAA — narrower spread between its good-credit and bad-credit customers than any other major insurer, but you must be military, a veteran, or immediate family to join.
• Nationwide — weights credit moderately and frequently prices well for mid-tier credit.
• American Family — its credit tier jumps are gentler than Allstate's or GEICO's across much of the Midwest.
• Root Insurance — prices mainly off an in-app driving test, leaving credit a smaller slice of the final rate.
• Erie Insurance — a Mid-Atlantic and Midwest regional that has historically kept credit weighting light.
• Auto-Owners Insurance — concentrated in the Midwest and Southeast, and less credit-sensitive than the national names.

Progressive and GEICO market aggressively to subprime-credit shoppers, yet they still tend to bill those customers well above their better-credit ones. A big advertising budget is not the same thing as a discount. Pulling three or four quotes side by side matters more for this profile than for any other, because the distance between the cheapest and priciest quote on a bad-credit driver regularly tops $1,000 a year.

Where Credit-Based Scoring Is Banned or Limited

A short list of states forbids carriers from pricing personal auto policies on credit:

• California — Proposition 103 rules credit out as a rating factor.
• Hawaii — credit is barred from auto rating altogether.
• Massachusetts — regulators there refuse to allow credit-based pricing.
• Michigan — the 2020 no-fault overhaul ended the practice.
• Washington — an emergency ban arrived in 2021, then gave way to tighter limits on how credit may be applied.

Live in one of them and your credit-based insurance score never touches the quote. Across the remaining 45 states and D.C., credit stays an active lever on price. Several others, Maryland included, limit credit use at renewal so a rate can't climb mid-policy just because a score slipped. These rules move; when a legislature is weighing credit-based scoring, the state insurance department's site is the quickest place to confirm where things stand.

Six Moves That Lower the Bill Right Away

Credit takes months or years to shift, but the levers below work today. Getting to cheap car insurance with bad credit generally isn't about repairing the score first — it's about stacking every discount and structural change available right now:

1. Quote five carriers minimum. On identical coverage for one driver profile, the spread between the low and high quote often clears 50%. Independent agents and online comparison tools both do the job; what counts is the number of quotes.
2. Join a telematics program. Progressive Snapshot, State Farm Drive Safe & Save, and Allstate Drivewise can take 10% to 40% off for anyone driving under 12,000 miles a year without hard-braking events.
3. Move the deductible from $500 to $1,000. That usually pulls 8% to 15% off a full-coverage premium. Leave it alone if the car is worth under $4,000.
4. Add renters or homeowners coverage. A renters policy costing as little as $180-a-year can unlock a multi-policy credit worth $200 to $400 on the auto side.
5. Pay the term up front or automate it. Most large carriers give 5% to 10% for paying in full, and autopay contributes another 3% to 5% while killing monthly installment fees.
6. Cut collision on an aging vehicle. Once the yearly premium plus the deductible nears half of what the car is worth, that coverage no longer adds up.

Non-Standard Carriers: Your Option After a Decline

When serious credit trouble comes packaged with a DUI, several accidents, or a gap in coverage, mainstream companies sometimes decline the application outright. Non-standard insurers exist for exactly this market — Dairyland, Direct Auto, GAINSCO, National General, The General, and Bristol West all court high-risk drivers who can't clear a preferred carrier's underwriting.

Know these two things before you sign a non-standard policy:

• The premium will nearly always exceed what a standard company would quote a clean driver, yet it's often the only route to legal, in-force coverage once the standard market shuts the door.
• Restrictions come with the territory — thinner default liability limits, fewer add-ons like rental reimbursement or roadside, and installment charges that can pile $60 to $120 per year onto the base premium.

Progressive plays in both the standard and non-standard markets, part of why it so often comes back cheapest for someone with poor credit and a shaky record. Its quote engine sweeps its own underwriting tiers on its own, so a driver who misses the preferred rate can still land a usable number under the same brand.

How Insurers Define 'Bad Credit'

The score most carriers use doesn't run on the FICO range you know. The common LexisNexis Attract Auto model uses a 200-to-997 scale, where roughly anything below 580 gets treated as 'poor' or 'non-standard' and anything past 776 counts as 'preferred.' Payment history and open revolving balances account for most of it, while hard inquiries, thin files, and a short credit history all drag it down.

When an insurer checks credit it's a soft inquiry, meaning your traditional credit report and FICO score are untouched. Most states let carriers rerate at renewal, so a rebound from 540 to 640 over a policy year can cut next year's premium even if nothing else about the driving profile changed.

Realistically, dragging a weak insurance score up to 'average' takes 6 to 18 months of on-time payments plus knocking revolving balances under 30% utilization. Shutting old accounts, opening a batch of new cards, or missing one payment mid-rebuild restarts the clock. After the score climbs, asking your current carrier for a mid-term re-rate is worth a five-minute call, since some will grant it rather than make you wait for renewal.

Frequently Asked Questions

How much extra does poor credit add to a car insurance premium?

In states where credit rating is legal, drivers with poor credit generally pay 60% to 115% more than excellent-credit drivers for the same coverage. Applied to a policy that runs $1,200 a year at excellent credit, that works out to roughly $1,900 to $2,600. Your state, your carrier, and the rest of your driving profile decide where in that band you land.

Which insurer is cheapest with bad credit?

No single carrier wins for every bad-credit driver, though USAA (for qualifying military families), Nationwide, American Family, and Root generally apply lighter credit surcharges than average. Progressive often competes well because it searches its own standard and non-standard tiers. Collecting five quotes beats committing to one brand up front.

Will anyone insure me with a 500 credit score?

Yes. Credit alone doesn't get an application declined — it just raises the price. A 500 typically drops a driver into a non-standard tier, where premiums are elevated but coverage stays readily available from carriers such as Dairyland, The General, National General, or Progressive's non-standard tier. Comparing at least three quotes is critical at this credit level because pricing scatters widely.

How fast does improved credit show up in my rate?

Most companies recheck the credit-based insurance score at every renewal, usually every six or twelve months. Real improvement from steady on-time payments and lower utilization tends to register within 6 to 18 months. Some insurers permit a mid-term re-rate on request after a full-tier jump, so a phone call following a big gain is worth making.

Do any car insurance companies skip the credit check?

Carriers in California, Hawaii, Massachusetts, and Michigan aren't allowed to use credit as a rating factor. Elsewhere, a few regional and non-standard companies downplay credit, but nearly all still pull an insurance score when they quote. The surest ways to avoid credit-based rating are living in a banned state or buying from a usage-based insurer like Root, where driving behavior sets most of the price.

Related guides

Pay Per Mile Car Insurance: Is It Right for Your Driving?

How Long Does a Car Insurance Quote Last Before Expiring?

Non Owner Car Insurance: Who Needs It and What It Costs